Court dismisses NVP case against EC

An Accra High Court on Monday declined to grant an injunction filed against the Electoral Commission (EC) preventing it from printing the December 7, presidential ballot papers.

The court noted that the EC would suffer hardship as it prepare for the country’s general elections.


According to the court personal should not override that of public interest stressing that the hardship the EC would suffer cannot be compared to that of the individual.


The court presided over Sir Justice Dennis Agyei, a Court of Appeal Judge sitting with additional responsibility as a High Court Judge therefore awarded cost of GH¢500 against the New Vision Party, which dragged the EC to court.


The court noted that it had the jurisdiction to look at the substantive issues concerning the EC’s refusal to accept the NVP’s nominations forms.


On October 31, this year, after the NVP had sent the matter to court, it raised issue as whether it had the jurisdiction to preside over the case and interim injunction against the EC seeking an order to halt it from printing the December 7, presidential ballot papers.

The NVP had proceeded to the High Court after the EC had rejected its presidential nomination form on October 18, this year. The EC had rejected the NVP presidential nomination form, saying the forms were full of blank spaces, contrary to the requirement for completing the forms.


According to the EC, it had a constitutional duty to conduct the presidential and parliamentary elections scheduled for December 7 and any delay in carrying out the necessary preparation for the election would be detrimental to the whole nation.


It had therefore prayed the court to dismiss the application as it had no merit.


At the court's sitting on October 31, Mr J.K. Yeboah, counsel for NVP told the court that NVP, led by Prophet Daniel Nkansah had complied with Constitutional Instrument 75 by filling the presidential nomination forms.


However, he said, the EC, under the same Constitutional Instrument, rejected the forms without any justifying cause, adding that the action of the Commission constituted a breach of the candidate's rights as a corporate citizen.

According to Mr Agyemang, the High Court had the jurisdiction to hear the matter as no election had been conducted and they were not challenging the validity of a person who had been elected.


On the injunction, Mr Agyemang said the EC, after rejecting the presidential nomination form of the NVP; the presidential candidate had moved another step by balloting for positions on the ballot paper.


The NVP contended further that a great hardship would be inflicted on the party should it win the substantive case and the EC is subsequently directed to accept the nomination form.


“This is a clear case where the wheel of the law applies its brake on the defendant to stop any further movement,” the party added.


The EC, represented by Mr James Quarshie-Idun, had filed the Commission’s affidavit in opposition to the two applications.